Tuesday, 16 July 2013

Waiting for Godot, Samuel Beckett

Apparently in his later years, occupied with ever-more minimalist statements of his preoccupations, Beckett regarded Godot as far too long and verbose. It is certainly in quite a different key to dramaticules like Catastrophe and Come and Go, but that very sense of space and elasticity allows it to trace the currents of human companionship in ways the stricter later work cannot. Miracle Theatre, a company specialising in outdoor productions in the summer, did justice to this marvellous piece in a production which hit both the comic and tragic keys at the right moment. Steve Jacobs and Angus Brown played off each other as Estragon and Vladimir, and Ben Dyson was a remarkable Pozzo, whose voice had something of Minder about it. Ciaran Clarke was Lucky, delivering the famous monologue with a tentative air, as if this was indeed the last 'thinking' he would ever do. The raised area - presumably for touring purposes - brought out the isolation of this Everyman pair, and the beautiful poetry towards the end did its work even on an audience more geared, it seemed, for laughter than tears. It was good that during the production money was raised for a worthy cause, but I can't approve of a great work like this being interrupted by a half-hour interval with a raffle (I saw it at the Theatre Roytal, Winchester). What is the play about? By the day I grow more antagonistic towards academic interpretation, which is often simply a way of pulling something strange into something more familiar. And I cite Beckett as my witness: 'As for wanting to find in all that a broader, loftier meaning to carry away from the performance, along with the program and the Eskimo pie, I cannot see the point of it. But it must be possible ...' (Eskimo pie??)

The Amen Corner, James Baldwin

Rufus Norris's revival of James Baldwin's 1955 play has been a great summer hit for the National. That is in part owing to the wonderful music, with the London Community Gospel Choir led by the Rev Bazil Meade belting out a succession of hymns (could a Harlem community church have been that good?) and a jazz trio playing a through-composed jazz score by Tim Sutton. But The Amen Corner is a play with music, not a musical, and the drama was played with great strength and subtlety. Marianne Jean-Baptiste played Sister Margaret, dominant pastor of her church, who is confronted by the return of a prodigal and terminally ill husband and the departure of a wayward musical son. Her position in the community, meanwhile, is threatened by a rebellious congregation stirred up by a rival elder (Cecilia Noble). A two-tier set brought out the two parts of Sister Margaret's life effectively. The jazz musicians in the space above perhaps made the church hall somewhat less than  realistic (especially when you can see the red light on the digital keyboard - surely it could be covered up with a bit of masking tape), and the Olivier's cosmic space was filled out with tenement scenes that were unnecessary but added atmosphere. Three-act plays are a challenge in a theatre where the convention is to have just one interval, and it was perhaps inevitable that the first half (ie two acts) felt rather long. But the third act took us to an enormously affecting conclusion, with text and music in perfect balance. And all accessible for £12, thanks to those amazing Travelex folk.

The Petrarchan Sonnet

Here's a brief guide to the form of sonnet known as the Petrarchan. Of interest, perhaps, to students of poetry and the general reader.

Like many poetic forms and terms, the sonnet is Italian in origin. It was used by the fourteenth-century Italian poet Petrarch (1304-74), and introduced to England in the sixteenth century by the poets Sir Thomas Wyatt (1503-42)and Surrey (full name Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, ?1517-47). They made translations of Petrarch and wrote English sonnets which employed his rhyme scheme.
Basic form
The basic shape of the Petrarchan sonnet is 8 lines (the octave or octet) + 6 lines (the sestet). The octave is composed of two quatrains, closely linked by just two rhyme sounds: abbaabba. The sestet has various rhyme forms, using either two or three rhyme sounds: cdcdcd, cde cde  etc. Many variations are permitted, but the sonnet should not end with a couplet. The English iambic pentameter line is the standard metre. In graphic form, here is the rhyme scheme of a sonnet divided into octave and a sestet, the setet itself divided into two tercets liniked by rhyme.
  1. ___________ a
  2. ___________ b
  3. ___________ b
  4. ___________ a
  5. ___________ a
  6. ___________ b
  7. ___________ b
  8. ___________ a
     9. ____________ c
     10. ___________ d
     11. ___________ c

     12. ___________ d
     13. ___________ c
     14. ___________ d


One thing to look out for in a sonnet is the turn (Italian volta), the point between the octave and sestet, where the sonnet moves from one rhyme group to another.  With the change in rhyme scheme may come a change in subject  matter.  So in the second, shorter half, the poet may change register, comment on the first half (perhaps presenting it as an analogy), answer it, resolve its tensions or heighten them, or reverse  the feeling altogether, among many other strategies.
A sonnet is a little too long for simple lyrical expression, but too short to tell a complex narrative. It therefore suits short argument, and the representation of an internal mental / emotional experience, often involving conflicting feelings.  This figuring of an internal passage of thought invites metaphorical language. Originally, the predominant theme was love, with the Petrarchan lover in joy and agony, burning and freezing at the sight of his beautiful / remote beloved. Wyatt and Surrey were courtly poets, writing about the delicate sensitivities of the courtly lover. Later writers have adopted the form for a wide range of subjects. Rhyming is harder in English than Italian, so the form also represents a formidable technical challenge to the poet. The discipline of the form seems to be an effective way of presenting strong emotional content.
Here are some examples of English sonnets using the Petrarchan form.
Wyatt
The long love that in my heart doth harbor
And in mine heart doth keep his residence,
Into my face presseth with bold pretense,
And there campeth, displaying his banner.
She that me learneth to love and to suffer,
And wills that my trust and lust's negligence
Be reined by reason, shame, and reverence,
With his hardiness taketh displeasure.
Wherewith love to the heart's forest he fleeth,
Leaving his enterprise with pain and cry,
And there him hideth and not appeareth.
What may I do when my master feareth
But in the field with him to live and die?
For good is the life ending faithfully.

Let's look at this without reference to the Italian model. It stands or falls as a poem in English, after all. I like the way it gets on with telling its story straightaway. Each line in the first quatrain tells us about a new event, an internal experience figured in imagery. 'Long love' - the length is felt through the double stress, which lengthens the vowels and gives the liquid 'l' sound its full value ('l' does seem to have an erotic feel to it: the lovely long-legged lady whiplash; Nabokov comments on this at the start of Lolita). The poet / lover is talking about love felt for a long time, and along with this temporal sense we get a spatial one: we see a long ship in harbour (inactive, frustrated). Like a royal visitor, Love takes up residence in the heart, which we might see in line 2 as a country house (nobles were supposed to keep these vast houses just in case the monarch decided to honour them by living there with the attendant swarm of court locusts; is there a passing echo of a castle keep?). But then, in lines three to four, something happens. Bored of harbouring and residing - a passive, skulking state - Love announces himself. He presses into the lover's face: he must have made some sign (A smile? A blush? A leer? Can I buy you a drink?) to the Lady. Love is out in the open, exposed, displaying his banner like an army in its camp.

Huge faux pas! The second quatrain looks at the Lady's reaction to this boldness. She's not pleased. He should have been a proper English gentleman, reserved and repressed. She has been teaching him to love in painful discretion ('to love and to suffer') int he best traditions of courtly love, where love is a debilitating illness which can drive you crazy. The phrase 'trust and lust's negligence' doesn't quite work for me: the double rhyme is an awkward jingle, and I can see how he has neglected his 'trust' (she trusted him to keep quiet), but not his lust, whatever sense of 'lust' we take (at that time it could mean vigorous and healthy). Maybe the 'r' allteration is a little overdone, too. But the great debate with Wyatt is how much this rough metre and sound is deliberate, and how much a sign of apprenticeship. we've seen how he departs from iambic opentameter right at the start with 'The long love', and the jingly-jangly sound of these lines could possibly convey some of the nervousness of the lover. We notice, anyway, that the second quatrain, like the first, is a complete sentence; but while the first quatrain had a fresh clause in each line, each with its precise verb (harbour ... keep), this has just one. The whole construction builds to that tremendous disapproval: 'taketh displeasure'.

We're now at the volta, the turning point between the octave and the sestet, and sure enough we get a dramatic development. Love, abashed at the beloved's displeasure, flees 'into the heart's forest' (giving us the millionth pun on heart and 'hart' (deer), the Elizabethan equivalent of rhyming 'love' and 'stars above'). It's a remarkable figuring forth of an internal seizure, the actual experience of turning inwards in shame. (And it reminds me of an episode of The Simpsons, in which Lisa disappoints a suitor on camera: 'Freeze it there,' says Bart. 'You can see the exact moment when his heart breaks!'). 'Pain and cry' is the image of the internal wound, the freeze frame instant where the lover gives up. Wyatt has a cdccdd rhyme going on here, making the sestet a compact merging of triple rhymes. In the last lines Love transmutes again (Love has been a ship, a royal visitor, a herald or king displaying his banner, a hunted quarry), this time into a master whom the lover, faithful servant, must follow even unto death, as Kent follows Lear. The Lover is loyal, and with this stoical virtue, huddled under the bedclothes, a pitiful wreck, he leaves us. The poem is an elaborate game of codes, all based on the court: the visitation, battle campaigns, the accepted code of practice of courtly love, the hunt, the duty of service. All translated into the poetic code of the sonnet, which puts it all togetehr in a little drama of love and rejection. What is remarkable is that through all the elaborateness, the rhymes and alliterations and witty double senses, we do feel something real going on: the poem gets at the psychology of love in a way that reaches beyond the Renaissance community of understanding: love can take over us, be a bore even. It can be martial and predatory - a ship, a herald of war - but it can be awfully embarrassing, too, and, when dismissed, takes us over in self-pity and absurd self-dramatisation. The artifice of the sonnet is a gateway to the genuine.



Milton

When I consider how my light is spent
     Ere half my days in this dark world and wide,
     And that one talent which is death to hide
     Lodged with me useless, though my soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
     My true account, lest he returning chide,
     "Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?"
     I fondly ask. But Patience, to prevent
That murmur, soon replies: "God doth not need
     Either man's work or his own gifts: who best
     Bear his mild yoke, they serve him best. His state
Is kingly; thousands at his bidding speed
     And post o'er land and ocean without rest:
     They also serve who only stand and wait."



Wordsworth, "London, 1802"

Milton! thou shouldst be living at this hour:

England hath need of thee: she is a fen

Of stagnant waters: altar, sword, and pen,

Fireside, the heroic wealth of hall and bower,

Have forfeited their ancient English dower

Of inward happiness. We are selfish men;

Oh! raise us up, return to us again;

And give us manners, virtue, freedom, power.

Thy soul was like a Star, and dwelt apart;

Thou hadst a voice whose sound was like the sea:

Pure as the naked heavens, majestic, free,

So didst thou travel on life's common way,

In cheerful godliness; and yet thy heart

The lowliest duties on herself did lay.



Amy Lowell ‘A Fixed Idea’


What torture lurks within a single thought
When grown too constant, and however kind,
However welcome still, the weary mind
Aches with its presence. Dull remembrance taught
Remembers on unceasingly; unsought
The old delight is with us but to find
That all recurring joy is pain refined,
Become a habit, and we struggle, caught.
You lie upon my heart as on a nest,
Folded in peace, for you can never know
How crushed I am with having you at rest
Heavy upon my life. I love you so
You bind my freedom from its rightful quest.
In mercy lift your drooping wings and go.

R B Kitaj, Pallant House




Looking at Kitaj at Pallant House I was reminded of T S Eliot’s  ‘dissociation of sensibility’ - the idea, roughly speaking,  that somewhere in our cultural history feeling and intellect became uncoupled. For a poet like Donne, an emotional experience could take the form of an intellectual adventure: the search for religious truth, for example, occupies mind and heart symbiotically, and we feel that in the pulse of the verse rhythms.  But now emotion goes one way – prompted by the stimulus of the quick hit – and intellect is left to find its own dessicated form elsewhere. Kitaj’s paintings represent a new synthesis of brain and emotion. Take ‘The Killer-Critic Assasinated by his Widower, Even’ (1997) – the work prompted by the recent death from an aneurism of Kitaj’s wife Sandra, which Kitaj blamed on the negative critical reactions to his Tate Retrospective of 1994. Clashing colour, gestural scrawl and grotesque imagery communicate a tactile, trembling fury. Yet it’s a fury felt through a dense web of association: the title alludes to Duchamp, the central image to Manet’s 'Assassination of Maximilian' (while the victim’s hands surely point to Goya’s 3rd May – Kitaj had a long and intense immersion in Spanish culture). Modernist collage points us in further directions, to revenge tragedy, to Erasmus and Gogol and their subjects of fools and madmen. The heart’s passion quickens the mind’s dance. It’s a language we are more used to in literature, in particular in Eliot’s ‘The Waste Land’, at once the scrapbook of a hyper-educated memory and the verbal reflex of mental disintegration. Densely allusive art requires time to unpack in the mind, but like Eliot, Kitaj can deploy his art to convey sudden sensuous beauty. ‘Degas’ (1980), shown in a room devoted to Kitaj’s figurative pastels, is a moving and beautiful work showing the hand and eye of an Old Master. Some excerpts of John Ashbery’s essay on the artist are reproduced in Paris Review:

Andrew Greig, Dunsinane (Radio 3 Drama)


Macbeth ends with regime change. A foreign army (England) helps to kill a tyrant and installs a new King, Malcolm. But then what? Could the transfer of power really be so smooth? Would the foreign army simply melt away, or would it need to stay to manage the transition to the new power? How much do we know about the new leader – the oddly empty character Malcolm – anyway? These were the questions that occurred to Scottish playwright David Greig when he saw a number of productions of the Scottish play in 2004. Dunsinane is his response. We start with the English under General Siward defeating Macbeth at Dunsinane: immediately our own certainties crumble, as we have a revisionist version of Macbeth’s demise and his wife, the Lady Gruach, turns out to be alive. The bluff certainties of Siward, which are fine in combat, quickly fall apart in this new territory of clan warfare, treachery and spells. Imprisonment, suicide, torture and infanticide follow. Malcolm understands this world, the English do not: conflict, Malcolm explains, is the natural state of things, peace an illusory, momentary calm sea. Greig’s play crystallises the issues of recent British adventures abroad, principally in Iraq and Afghanistan; and it is apposite too in the light of any ideas that, rid of Gaddafi, Libya will turn dutifully to the Western model. Attention is focussed on the bewildered and brutalised English squaddies, and the chief perspective is that of Siward, holding on as long as possible to Blairite sense of mission.  The play did not seem to me entirely consistent: the squaddie humour seemed formulaic, and the ending did not quite have the climactic feel it was looking for: hard to find a climax to a scenario that is all to do with grinding on in a sense of ever greater futility. However, the entire production was gripping. Powerful performances by Jonny Phillips (Siward) and Siobhan Redmond (Gruach) brought out the bare poetry of Grieg’s script. A welcome repeat on Radio 3’s Sunday drama slot.

Barbara Hepworth, Hospital Drawings (Pallant House)


Art and medicine have a long history. From the wounds of Christ to Rembrandt’s ‘The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Tulp’, from miracle healings to the casualties of war and the faces of the insane, the subjects of art invite us to look with an eye at once compassionate and forensic at the vulnerable body and mind.  In the  series of 70 drawings by Barbara Hepworth of operations in a hospital theatre the artist and the doctor come particularly close . These works originated in the friendship of Hepworth and Exeter orthopaedic surgeon Norman Capener, who in 1944 treated Hepworth’s daughter Sarah, who suffered from osteomyelitis (now treated with antibiotics, but then requiring complex surgery). A lifelong friendship followed. Capener was himself an amateur artist and Hepworth taught him sculpture;  Capener in turn designed some surgical instruments based on Hepworth’s sculpting tools. Between 1947 and 1949 Hepworth witnessed, and drew, operations performed by Capener and colleagues. The drawings bring out the remarkable connections between artist and surgeon: Capener was devising his own ‘philosophy of the hand’ and the drawings show hands in the actions in the actions of praying, blessing, probing, exploring  - each action echoed by the act of drawing, or rather incising, as Hepworth cut her way with a scalpel-like pencil into a board prepared with a gesso layer. This is a technique we associate with Renaissance drawing, and the groups of figures in these works look like the nativities and pietàs of renaissance art: clinical procedures assume the grace and gravitas of spiritual rituals.  The quality of absolute attention – from surgeon to patient, from artist to surgeon - draws in our own gaze, while at the same time the white masked bodies of the doctors appear to us transfigured into the pure shapes of Hepworth’s sculptural forms.

The Captain of Köpenick



The Captain of Köpenick (Olivier, National Theatre), by Carl Zuckmayer. Play based on the  true story of a prisoner, Wilhelm Voigt, who finds himself without papers and to all state intents and purposes thus without identity or even existence. Dressed up in a captain's uniform, however, he is able to lead some passing soldiers on an expedition to seize the contents of the treasury of the town hall. The production was held together by the amazing Anthony Sher. The first half dragged, with satirical society scenes and a sentimental subplot or two, which didn't carry much narrative power. It took off in the second half, though, with the central 'raid' scenes brought off with riotous humour. As so often in the Olivier, design concepts were needed to fill the vast spaces, and so we had huge skyscapes, dancing dummies and so forth. It all looked magnificent but rather over-produced. Somewhere in there amid all the dazzle and choreography was an ensemble play about a venal society and the Prussian reverence for uniform that lay behind the rise of Hitler. But it had the feel of a quintet being played by a symphony orchestra. Best moment was Sher, 'pots and pans'.